Best Smart Scales for Body Composition in 2026 (5 Picks)
Quick answer: The Withings Body Smart is the safest all-round smart scale: Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, Apple Health sync and no Withings+ fee for core readings. The Garmin Index S2 suits Garmin owners (up to 16 users) and the Renpho Elis 1 is the budget pick. Treat body fat as a trend, and skip impedance readings if you have a pacemaker.
If you already wear a screenless fitness tracker or a smart ring, a scale is the missing half of the picture. Your band knows your sleep and heart rate. It has no idea whether the last eight weeks of lifting did anything to your weight or lean mass. A Wi-Fi scale fills that gap without another subscription, as long as you know what its body fat number can and cannot tell you.
This is a research roundup, not a test report. We read manufacturer pages and support articles, independent reviews and the published research on impedance (BIA) scales, then ranked by fit. Where a source blocked us or a number is old, we say so.
Which smart scales are worth buying, side by side?
Five scales cover most buyers: two Withings models, the Garmin Index S2, the Eufy P2 Pro and the Renpho Elis 1. They differ more in app sync and user handling than in raw weight accuracy.
| Scale | Price | Users | Connectivity | Third-party sync | Weight-only mode |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Withings Body Smart | $129.95 (Withings US, per Gainframe, Sep 29, 2026) | 8 (per CoolThings, Jan 2025) | Wi-Fi + Bluetooth | Apple Health; Android via Health Connect (reports vary) | Yes (Withings support) |
| Garmin Index S2 | $149.99 at 2020 launch; current price not verified | Up to 16 (Garmin) | Wi-Fi (Garmin Connect app for setup) | Little; bridge apps needed | Yes (per Garage Gym Reviews) |
| Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro | Not verified | Not confirmed | Wi-Fi + Bluetooth | Apple Health, Google Fit, Fitbit (2022 launch coverage) | Yes, "Simple Mode" (Eufy support) |
| Renpho Elis 1 | Not verified | Unlimited profiles, one shared login | Bluetooth only | Apple Health, Google Fit, Samsung Health, Fitbit (CoolThings) | Not confirmed |
| Withings Body Scan | $499.95 (Withings US listing, per search snippet; unconfirmed) | Not confirmed | Wi-Fi + Bluetooth | Apple Health (Withings app) | Yes (Withings support) |
Prices are manufacturer or reported US list prices, not Amazon prices. Withings.com blocked our automated access on November 7, 2026, so Withings figures come from third-party reports and may have changed. Check live listings.
- Best all-round: Withings Body Smart for sync, multi-user support and no fee for core readings
- Best for Garmin users: Garmin Index S2 for 16 profiles and automatic Garmin Connect sync
- Best on a budget: Renpho Elis 1 for 13 measurements, with Bluetooth only
- Most measurements for the money: Eufy P2 Pro for 16 readings and Wi-Fi, if you can find stock
- Splurge: Withings Body Scan for segmental body composition plus ECG, at about four times the Body Smart
Is the Withings Body Smart the best all-round smart scale?
Yes, for most people, in our assessment. The Body Smart combines Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, Apple Health sync through the Withings iPhone app, and automatic user recognition. Gainframe's September 2026 comparison notes that core scale measurements do not require Withings+, the optional paid tier. CoolThings lists it at eight users and eight key metrics.
Withings and Eufy both publish a weight-only mode for people who need to avoid impedance (more on that below). The honest downsides: it costs more than the Eufy and Renpho scales, and Android sync to Health Connect gets mixed reports, with some body composition values staying inside the Withings app. We could not open Withings.com, so confirm the live price and features there.
Amazon's Body Smart listing showed an active buy button when we checked on November 7, 2026, as did the Garmin Index S2 listing below; the Eufy P2 Pro listing showed "Currently unavailable."
Is the Garmin Index S2 worth it if you wear a Garmin?

Only if Garmin Connect is already where your data lives. Garmin says the Index S2 holds up to 16 users, syncs over Wi-Fi to your Garmin Connect account with no phone needed after setup, and runs up to nine months on its batteries (press release, October 14, 2020). It reports weight, body fat, BMI, skeletal muscle mass, bone mass and body water.
The drawbacks are real. DC Rainmaker found the S2's body fat ran roughly 2 to 2.5 points higher than the original Index while weight matched within about 0.1 lb, and he pointed to trends rather than absolute values. Garage Gym Reviews lists the lack of third-party app integration as a con, and describes the scale as one of the pricier options. It launched at $149.99 and we could not verify today's Garmin price. If you pair it with the Garmin Cirqa, everything stays in one app. If you want Apple Health, expect a bridge app.
Is the Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro a good value pick?
On specs, yes. At launch in April 2022, Notebookcheck described 16 measurements, a claimed 50 g (0.11 lb) accuracy, Wi-Fi updates without needing your phone nearby, and EufyLife app sync to Apple Health, Google Fit and Fitbit. Notebookcheck also noted the 50 g figure is Eufy's own claim. That precision covers weight, not body fat.
The catch for this page is stock, covered above, so use the search link and check Eufy's own store. Eufy's support page names the P1, P2 series (including the P2 Pro) and P3 and says it is not recommended for people who wear pacemakers to use the body composition function, and that Simple Mode turns the scale into weight-only.
Is the Renpho Elis 1 accurate enough for a budget buyer?
It is a fair trend tracker at the lowest cost in this list. CoolThings (January 21, 2025) describes 13 measurements, Bluetooth only with no Wi-Fi, three included AAA batteries, a 400 lb limit, and sync to Fitbit, Apple Health, Google Fit and Samsung Health. Its on-scale display shows only weight, in 0.2 lb steps.
Two caveats. Profiles are unlimited, but they share one login, so everyone in the house can see everyone else's numbers. And the Renpho Health app is free to download, but we saw conflicting reports about premium upsells, so check what the app asks you to pay for. We could not find Renpho's pacemaker guidance on a primary page, so if you have an implant, read the manual that comes in the box before you use the body composition features.
Is the Withings Body Scan worth about four times the price?
Only if you want the extras, and they are not about better fat percentages. The Body Scan adds segmental body composition, a handle with an ECG, and an electrodermal activity score, and was reported at about $499.95 in search results for Withings' US store. We could not open Withings' page, so treat that price, and any bundled Withings+ trial, as unconfirmed.
Those ECG and nerve-activity features are wellness readings, not a diagnosis, and a scale cannot replace an appointment. For body weight and a fat trend, the Body Smart covers the same ground for far less. If you do want the Body Scan, check stock on Withings directly; our Amazon check was inconclusive.
How accurate is the body fat reading on a smart scale?
Good for trends, weak for absolute numbers. Home scales send a small current from foot to foot (bioelectrical impedance, or BIA) and estimate fat from how the current travels. That estimate assumes your body water is stable, which it often is not.
The research backs the caution. A 2008 study of 106 adults compared three foot-to-foot devices and one hand-to-foot device with MRI and DXA and concluded the foot-to-foot setups agreed less well for individuals, recommending tetrapolar electrodes for individual use (Bosy-Westphal et al., Obesity Facts). A 2023 study of 188 healthy adults found 50 kHz BIA underestimated fat mass versus DXA (Nescolarde et al., Nutrients). Neither study tested these exact scales, so read them as a limit on the method, not a ranking.
What to do about it: weigh at the same time of day, ideally in the morning, with similar hydration, and judge the multi-week line, not a single morning. Our inference: pairing a scale with the weekly trend from your tracker is more useful than chasing one fat percentage. Our guides on smart kitchen scales for calorie tracking and no-subscription calorie tracking cover the food side of the same loop.
Can you use a smart scale if you have a pacemaker?
Not for body composition without talking to your clinician first. Smart scales pass a small electrical signal through your body, and manufacturers say so. Withings' safety FAQ says you should not use the Body Smart if you wear a pacemaker or other internal medical device. For people who already own one, Withings' support page offers Weight-Only Mode, which disables impedance-based features for every user on the scale, and recommends it for a pacemaker or a metallic implant such as an intramedullary rod, with a note to consult your doctor first. Eufy says it is not recommended to use the body composition function with a pacemaker, and its Simple Mode turns the scale into weight-only. Garage Gym Reviews lists a do-not-use warning for the Garmin Index S2 with a pacemaker or other internal electric devices; we could not find Garmin's own manual wording. Check the maker's manual for any scale you buy.
Independent work points the same way. A 2023 Heart Rhythm study using simulations and bench tests found these devices could interfere with cardiac implantable electronic devices, with scales and rings producing less interference than smartwatches, and it did not recommend their use in this population (Ha et al., Heart Rhythm). A 2025 research letter in Circulation: Arrhythmia and Electrophysiology (Hansen et al.) tested a smartwatch and a smart scale, the Withings BodyScan, on 27 patients with implanted devices. It saw interference in 5 of 27, in patients whose implant was set to maximum sensitivity, and none in patients whose sensitivity had been adjusted. That adjustment is a clinic decision, and it was a small single-center pilot. The risk depends on the implant and its settings, so this is a question for your cardiologist or device clinic, not a buying guide. If you have an implant, ask before you step on any of these scales, including in weight-only mode.
Do smart scales need a subscription?
Not for the readings that matter here. Gainframe's September 2026 comparison states core Withings scale measurements do not require Withings+, an optional tier. Garmin's S2 syncs to a Garmin Connect account and we found no scale fee, though Garmin now sells a paid Connect+ plan, so see our breakdown of Garmin Connect+ before you assume everything is free. Eufy and Renpho run on free apps, with the Renpho upsell caveat above.
Which smart scales sync with Apple Health, Google Health, Fitbit or Garmin?
Apple Health is the easy one. The Withings, Eufy and Renpho scales list it. Garmin is the odd one out, with limited third-party sync. For Android, older reviews list Google Fit, and Google is moving the Fitbit app to Google Health, so our inference is to test the connection on your own phone before you commit. Our Fitbit app and Google Health guide covers what changed.
The Fitbit Aria Air is the natural match for Fitbit users, and CoolThings described it as a three-measurement scale. We could not confirm it is still sold, so we left it off the list.
Who should pick which smart scale?
| If you are... | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| On iPhone, want one scale for the household | Withings Body Smart | Apple Health sync, automatic user recognition, core data without Withings+ |
| A Garmin watch or Cirqa owner | Garmin Index S2 | Up to 16 users, direct Garmin Connect sync |
| Watching the budget | Renpho Elis 1 | 13 measurements, Bluetooth, multi-platform sync |
| Want the most readings and Wi-Fi | Eufy P2 Pro | 16 measurements; stock permitting |
| Want ECG and segmental data | Withings Body Scan | Premium extras, not a diagnosis |
| Have a pacemaker or implant | Ask your clinician first | Avoid impedance readings unless cleared |
Looking at fee-free wearables for the rest of the picture? See our best fitness trackers without a subscription and our kitchen gear for fitness tracker users. For heart-focused wearables, read trackers for heart health and AFib and talk to a clinician about any rhythm concern.
Smart Scale FAQ
What is the best smart scale for body composition?
The Withings Body Smart is the safest all-round pick in our research-based ranking: Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, Apple Health sync, multiple users, and core measurements that do not need a Withings+ subscription. The Garmin Index S2 is better if you already live in Garmin Connect. Neither is a medical device.
Are smart scale body fat readings accurate?
Not in absolute terms. Published studies found consumer foot-to-foot impedance scales agree less with DXA and MRI than lab-grade devices, and one 2023 study of 188 adults found 50 kHz impedance underestimated fat mass versus DXA. Use the number as a trend under the same conditions each time.
Can I use a smart scale if I have a pacemaker?
Ask your cardiologist or device clinic first. Withings says you should not use the Body Smart if you wear a pacemaker or other internal medical device, and offers Weight-Only Mode, which turns off impedance features, for people who already own one. Eufy says it is not recommended to use the body composition function with a pacemaker. One review of Garmin's scale lists a do-not-use warning for pacemakers, but we could not find Garmin's own manual wording, so check the manual for any scale you buy. A 2023 Heart Rhythm study and a small 2025 pilot study found these signals could interfere with cardiac implants.
Do smart scales require a subscription?
Not for the basics. Core Withings Body Smart measurements do not require Withings+, and the Garmin Index S2, Eufy P2 Pro and Renpho Elis 1 work through free apps. Check the in-app screens before you buy, because Renpho's app has drawn mixed reports about premium upsells.
Does a smart scale sync with Apple Health and Google Health?
Apple Health sync is listed for the Withings Body Smart, Eufy P2 Pro and Renpho Elis 1. The Garmin Index S2 has little third-party integration, so Apple Health needs a bridge app. Google Fit support is listed in older reviews, and Google is moving the Fitbit app to Google Health, so confirm sync on your own phone.
Is the Fitbit Aria Air still worth buying?
We could not confirm that it is still on sale. A January 2025 review described it as a three-measurement scale that suits Fitbit users, and retailer listings we found were mixed, so we left it out of the picks. Check the current Google store listing before you consider it.
Withings Body Smart vs Garmin Index S2: which should I buy?
Pick the Withings Body Smart for third-party app sync and Apple Health. Pick the Garmin Index S2 if your watch or screenless band already feeds Garmin Connect and you want up to 16 user profiles. The Garmin scale is older, and reviewers call it pricey.
Sources
- Garmin: Measure more with the Index S2 smart scale (press release, Oct 14, 2020)
- Eufy support: Can pregnant women or users with pacemakers use the scale?
- Withings support: Weight-Only Mode (pacemaker and implant guidance)
- Withings support: Body Smart, frequently asked questions about safety (pacemaker)
- Ha GB et al., Heart Rhythm 2023: smart scales, watches and rings with bioimpedance and cardiac implantable electronic devices (PubMed 36997272)
- Hansen N et al., Circ Arrhythm Electrophysiol 2025: smartwatches and smart scales and cardiac implantable electronic devices (PubMed 41328543)
- Bosy-Westphal A et al., Obesity Facts 2008: consumer BIA devices vs MRI and DXA (PubMed 20054195)
- Nescolarde L et al., Nutrients 2023: single-frequency BIA fat mass vs DXA (PubMed 37960291)
- DC Rainmaker: Garmin Index S2 in-depth review
- CoolThings: The best smart scales (Jan 21, 2025)
- Notebookcheck: Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro launch (Apr 5, 2022)
- Gainframe: Withings Body Smart vs Body Comp (US prices as of Sep 29, 2026)
- Garage Gym Reviews: Garmin Index S2 smart scale